Home / Blog

Hypothetical questions for couples: funny to impossible

A good what-if tells you more than a serious talk. Here are hypothetical questions for couples in four moods, from a talking fridge to a surprise move abroad, and how to ask them so the answer is honest.

Hypothetical questions for couples are specific what-ifs with one vivid image: you swap bodies for a day, the dog starts talking, money appears in the hallway. Ask one at a time, make it concrete. Here are 14 to start tonight; Future Us and Would You Still decks have hundreds more in the capybara cards app.

capybara cards team · 2026-10-15 · 3 min read

Hypothetical questions for couples are the shortcut to the conversation you would never start on purpose. Nobody wants to be asked "what do you want from life." Everyone wants to be asked what they would do with a talking dog. Same information, much better evening.

The rule is one clear picture per question. "What if we were rich" gets "I don't know, travel." "What if you found a bag with a million dollars in our hallway" gets a plan, a moral stance and probably an argument about the neighbors.

Four moods below: funny ones, future ones, jealous ones that stay playful, and impossible picks where both answers are bad. One section per evening is plenty.

Hypothetical questions for couples

Funny first. Ask these deadpan and make them commit to details.

• If our dog could talk for one day, what is the first secret of yours it would tell me?
• If we swapped bodies for a day, what is the first thing you would change about how I dress?
• If you found a bag with a million dollars in our hallway, what happens in the next ten minutes?
• If one of us had to live in a treehouse for a year, who goes, and who brings the snacks?

More of these are in the Would You Still Love Me If deck in the app. 156 more cards are in the Would You Still Love Me If... deck.

A deck of what-ifs for every moodcapybara cards has a Would You Still Love Me If deck for the ridiculous ones, Future Us for the big what-ifs and Would You Rather for the impossible picks. One phone, no setup, works on FaceTime too.Get the app

• Would You Still Love Me If...156 cards
• Future Us159 cards
• Would You Rather171 cards

Hypothetical questions for couples about the future

The big what-ifs, asked lightly. This is where couples accidentally learn something: who would move, who would stay, which tradition matters more than they admitted. Let the answer be short and then ask "why that one?" The why is the real answer.

• If a job offered you double your salary but in a city neither of us has heard of, do we go?
• If we could only keep one of our families' holiday traditions, which one survives?
• If we won a house tomorrow, but it had to be in the middle of nowhere, would you take it?
• If you had to pick our next pet right now, no discussion, what is it?

More of these are in the Future Us deck in the app. 159 more cards are in the Future Us deck.

Hypothetical questions for couples that are a little jealous

Playful, not pointed. Keep the stranger fictional and the stakes tiny, and if either of you has a real sore spot in this area, skip the section. The goal is a grin, not a quiet car ride home.

• If your celebrity crush slid into your messages tonight, do you reply before telling me, or after?
• If my ex offered you free tickets to the one concert you have waited years for, are you going?
• If a stranger said I looked like a famous person, which famous person would make you laugh the hardest?

More playful traps are in the Would You Still Love Me If deck in the app. 156 more cards are in the Would You Still Love Me If... deck.

Impossible hypothetical questions for couples

Both options are bad. Expect a debate.

• If you could only keep your phone or our couch for a year, which one goes?
• If we had to relive one week of our relationship on repeat forever, which week do you pick?
• If you could delete one holiday from the calendar for everyone, which one goes?

More impossible picks are in the Would You Rather deck in the app. 171 more cards are in the Would You Rather deck.

How to ask so you get a real answer

Ask one at a time, not a list. A list gets skimmed; one question gets answered. If the first reply is "I don't know", give them your own answer first and watch them correct it, because people find it much easier to disagree than to start from nothing. Make the answer concrete: "which city?" "which week?" Guess their answer before they say it and keep score if you like. And answer every question yourself too, because a what-if game only works when both of you are on the spot.

Over text or on a call, send one and wait for the reply before the next. Keeping a deck open on one phone means you never run out, and the surprise is real for both of you.